OP-ED: PG&E Should be Fined But Not Forced int...

OP-ED: PG&E Should be Fined But Not Forced into Bankruptcy by


Apply now for FREE financial aid. The deadline is Friday, March 2, 2019 to apply for a Cal Grant or Middle Class Scholarship. You may be eligible for an award up to $12,570 depending on what campus you attend: a California community college or vocational educational institution, California State University, University of California, or eligible private non-profit or proprietary college or university. Visit for application assistance or contact the California Student Aid Commission at 1-888-CA-GRANT or visit us online at more information. We’re on social media @castudentaid.

By Wil Hardee

PG&E is about to receive a hefty fine for their role in the San Bruno tragedy – and it should. The Oakland African American Chamber of Commerce believes PG&E should pay. However, we also believe the men and women who benefit from the company, as a job creator, economic engine and supporter of diversity and inclusion in the work place, shouldn’t pay the price too.

PG&E may reportedly be fined up to $2.25 billion and if it is forced to pay that much, we should assume the company won’t be able to pay for the billions of dollars it is investing to improve crucial infrastructure.

In fact, it has been reported that PG&E may have to file for bankruptcy if the fine is so high. The money that goes to make infrastructure improvements – the jobs they create and the revenue they generate – is money East Bay businesses big and small can’t afford to see go away.

Additionally, if PG&E can no longer afford to invest in our communities, we will lose a partner with a proven track record of supporting diversity. The company was ranked as the top regional utility for diversity efforts in 2012 and is among the top ten companies in the entire nation when it comes to supplier diversity, according to Diversity Inc. We need companies like that to remain on sound fiscal ground.

The CPUC should recognize that a fine of $2.25 billion would be 40 times that of any similar fine in our nation’s history – and that seems excessive. Perhaps if the agency realizes that it is not just PG&E who will pay a price, it will reconsider that figure.

PG&E should be fined and forced to pay help San Bruno rebuild and recover and to ensure that such a tragedy never happens again. Let’s make sure the fine it receives does not imperil its ability to improve our infrastructure, create jobs, spark local economic activity and foster diversity and inclusion in the work place.

Wil Hardee

Wil Hardee

Wil Hardee is president & CEO, Oakland African-American Chamber of Commerce


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *